Meet our wardens and vestry members


  • Holly Thomas Whitmore - Warden

    I am an area local, raised in Wainscott and currently living in Amagansett. I’m also a lifelong congregant of St. Luke’s, having first attended as a child with my parents. St. Luke’s has been a presence in many of my life’s most important moments; I received first Communion here, was married in the Church, my four children, and both of my grandchildren have all been baptized at St. Luke’s. My dedication to St. Luke’s has continued through participation as an active member of the Altar Guild, member of the Outreach Committee, participation in the Brown Bag Lunch Program, volunteer efforts at the annual Summer Fair, and once-upon-a-time as a Sunday School teacher.

  • Merle McDonald-AAron - Warden

    I was born on the Island of Trinidad and moved to the US in 1993.  I was brought up in the Anglican community and wanted to continue in my faith, so my late husband, Robert, introduced me to St Luke’s, and I have been attending since then, mostly at the 8:00am service.   St Luke’s has become my spiritual home, and when I am away, I look forward with anticipation to coming home to my St Luke's family.   I currently serve as a member of the Altar Guild.  I am a past president of the Montauk Chamber of Commerce and served on the Board of Directors of the Montauk Playhouse. Having served previously on the Vestry, I am honored to be of service again.

    Contact Merle at aaronm42@hotmail.com

  • David cavalier

    I was born and raised in Manhattan, where I was baptized, confirmed and later married at St. Thomas Church. It was in the pews of St. Thomas, listening to the choir that I first developed my love of the Episcopal musical tradition I attended Trinity School in Manhattan and then did my undergraduate de- gree at Yale and my graduate degree in history at Oxford. I was lucky to marry my wife, Opal and we are blessed to have three children, Olivia (9), Philippa (known as Pippa”, 7) and William (5). We live year-round in Sag Harbor and all of our children attend the Sag Harbor Elementary School. Olivia, Pippa and William also love Sunday School at St. Lukes and I believe at least two of them want to join the choir. 

    I started my career at Goldman Sachs in investment banking and then worked at Tiger Management. In my professional world, I ran a fund that invested in biotechnology companies and later served as CFO of a biodefense company. Currently, I am serving as the COO of a startup in the direct-to-consumer health and wellness sector. I also serve on the Board of a public biotechnology company developing immunotherapy approaches for ovarian and breast cancer. I am honored to serve as the Chairman of the New York Board of Enterprise Community Partners, a national charity focused on policy, capital and program initiatives to address the affordable housing crisis in the United States. At St. Lukes its been my privilege to sing in the choir and to serve on the 2030 Vision Committee. Im also an avid pilot based at East Hampton airport and a terrible, but enthusiastic, ice hockey player.

  • Janie Miller

    I began my journey in the Episcopal Church while living in Charleston, South Carolina. I attended what is now Grace Cathedral. There I found a thriving community of faith based Friends. I joined the flower guild and volunteered each year at our annual fund raising event. Over the last 45 years I have enjoyed a career in the Decorative Arts. And for 7 years I was on the board of Pathway's Greenwich, a mental health agency which houses the severely mentally ill. Arriving in East Hampton to live full time brought me to St Luke's Church. Once again I discovered a wonderful community of faith and warmth. It is my honor to be nominated for St. Luke's Vestry. I will take my responsibilities very seriously.

  • Erika Angulo Puig

    I have been living in East Hampton for five years, and coming to St. Luke’s for a year. I have two boys, one in the high school the other is working. St. Luke’s and the Episcopal church gives me the opportunity to practice my faith and this community’s acceptance of all people with love and without judgement is the reason for my being part of this faith community. I like that everybody from all walks of life are welcome. I like the work St. Luke’s does for the community, and that we are reaching out to the youth and Hispanic population. 



  • Teresa Schurr

    My name is Teresa Loper Schurr, I am a 12th Generation Bonacker. I am married to my husband Robert Schurr (we just celebrated our 25th wedding anniversary) and we have a daughter Samantha (19). Samantha has just fin- ished her first year at Mercyhurst University in Erie, PA. I have been a member of St. Lukes Church since my confirmation in 1976. I have been active with Sunday School as a teacher and helper as well as active in Outreach, I have been part of the annual family fair and participated for many years at our Christmas Bazar. I am a licensed insurance broker with Dayton Ritz & Osborne. I have been with the company for over 21 year's. I graduated from East Hampton High School in 1981. I am an avid bowler and go on many trips for tournaments with my team as well as a bowl in a weekly league. I also enjoy going to watch Samantha bowl with her college team at different matches.

  • Marcie Sohm

    Although I am the fifth generation of my family to come to East Hampton I have only recently come back to St Lukes. I joined the parish three years ago when my grown children wanted to return to the church. Since then I have volunteered at and served on the Summer Fair committee, helped with the decorations for Christmas and Easter and over this past year served as the Clerk on the Vestry. St Lukes has been a very important part of mine and my fam- ilys lives the past three years and I am grateful for all the support that we've found here. I look forward to the opportunity to give back to the community as a member of the Vestry.

  • Hugh Tilney

    I was born and spent the first 45 years of my life in the UK. In 1987 I moved to New York and met and married  Helene, my wife. I spent the first 25 years of his professional life in insurance at Lloyd's of London. After the move to New York, I was Chief Operating Officer of an investment management company from which I retired four years ago. Most recently, here at St. Luke’s I am a member of the Finance Committee, have attended this parish for many years and am impressed with the forward movement of our congregation in welcoming all people into our midst. I will do my best to contribute my ideas and care for St. Luke’s during my term on the Vestry.

  • SALVAtore tocci

    Sal started his high school science teaching career in Southold in 1971 and two years later moved to East Hampton High School where he taught biology and chemistry. Retired from teaching in 1997 to devote his full attention to writing, and authored a high school chemistry text, some 60 books on science for school libraries, and numerous state assessments, before retiring again to pursue interests in building a model railroad layout, learning Italian, taking piano lessons, and studying the Bible. His most enjoyable pastime is to travel with his wife Patti and to spend time with his two grandchildren Matthew and Mary Jo.



  • Jeffrey Sussman

    I have been a member of St. Luke's since 1986 and soon thereafter became a Eucharistic Minister. During the late 1980s, I served on the vestry when Fritz Creamer was rector. In addition, as head of my own marketing/PR compa- ny, I volunteered my services to promote concerts at St. Bartholomew Church in Manhattan. I also advised its rector, Tom Bowers, on several public relations issues. As a St. Luke's vestry member, I intend to use my professional expertise to help the church reach its goals of increasing its membership and promoting its good works to the community at large. In addition to my PR activities, I am the author of fourteen books; the newest will be published in the fall.

  • Justin Udelhofen - Treasurer

     I am grateful to have been raised in Cuba City, Wisconsin and now divide time between East Hampton and New York City. My wife Caroline and I found our home in St. Lukes during 2016 after returning north from Jacksonville, Florida. Her late grandfather Howard Dean served as Senior Warden and we are thankful for family and friends throughout St. Lukes and the community. Since graduating from Harvard College in 2002, my professional work has been in public equities. Having served on the Finance/ Investment Committee since 2018, and recently as Vestry Clerk, I aim to build on the great work undertaken over recent years. I seek to bring conservatism and analytical rigor toward continuing to strengthen our Parish and look forward to serving St. Lukes in this capacity.

Footer Text

This is just placeholder text.

This text will be on the bottom of every page on your site.